I was always the “fat girlfriend” until my boyfriend dumped me for my best friend—and six months later, on the day they were supposed to get married, I found out just how wrong he’d been about me.
Discover more
coffee
Comics
Bookshelves
Brown rice syrup
Shirts
Online movie streaming services
Car
I was the “fat girlfriend” my ex dumped for my best friend—then on their wedding day, his mom called me and said, “You do NOT want to miss this.”
I’m Larkin, 28F, and I’ve always been “the big girl.”
Not cute-thick. Just… big.
The one relatives corner at Thanksgiving to whisper about sugar. The one strangers tell, “You’d be so pretty if you lost a little weight.”
So I learned to be easy to love.
Funny, helpful, reliable.
The friend who shows up early to help set up, stays late to clean, remembers everyone’s coffee order.
If I couldn’t be the prettiest, I’d be the most useful.
That’s who Sayer (31M) met at trivia night.
He was with coworkers; I was with my friend Abby (27F). My team won, he joked about me “carrying the table,” I roasted his carefully groomed beard.
He asked for my number before the night ended.
He texted me first.
“You’re refreshing,” he wrote. “You’re not like other girls.
You’re real.”
Red flag in hindsight.
At the time, I melted.
We dated almost three years.
Shared Netflix accounts, weekends away, toothbrushes in each other’s places. We talked about moving in together, about maybe getting a dog, about “someday” kids.
My best friend Maren (28F) was part of that life.
We’d been friends since college. She’s tiny, blonde, naturally thin in a “I forgot to eat today” way that makes people roll their eyes and love her anyway.
She held my hand at my dad’s funeral.
She spent nights on my couch when my anxiety was bad.
She used to tell me, “You deserve someone who never makes you feel like a backup.”
Six months ago, that same girl was in my bed with my boyfriend.
Literally.
I was at work when my iPad lit up with a shared photo notification. Sayer and I had synced devices because we were cute and stupid.
I tapped it without thinking.
It was my bedroom.
My gray comforter.
My yellow throw pillow.
Sayer and Maren in the middle of it. Shirtless.
Laughing.
His hand on her hip. Her hair on my pillow.
For a second, my brain tried to convince me it was old or fake.
Then my stomach flipped.
“I have to go,” I told Abby, grabbing my bag.
“Are you okay?” she asked.
“No,” I said, and walked out.
Discover more
coffee
Comics
Car
Brown rice syrup
Online movie streaming services
Bookshelves
Shirts
I sat on my couch with that photo open and waited.
When Sayer walked in, he was humming. Tossed his keys in the bowl.
“Anything you want to tell me?” I asked.
He froze, saw the iPad, and in that moment, I watched the guilt flicker across his face and… fade.
He didn’t deny it.
He didn’t panic.
He just sighed.
“I didn’t mean for you to find out like this,” he said.
Not “I didn’t mean to do this.” Just… like this.
Maren stepped out of the hallway behind him.
Bare legs.
My oversized sweatshirt.
My friend.
“I trusted you,” I said. My voice sounded weirdly calm.
“Both of you.”
He shifted, like this was a negotiation.
“She’s just more my type,” he said. “Maren is thin.
She’s beautiful.
It matters.”
The room buzzed.
He kept going.
That was the line that really did it.
Matches me.
Like I was the wrong shoes for his suit.
Maren didn’t say a word. Not one. Just crossed her arms, eyes shining, and let him talk.
I gave him a trash bag for his things.
I told her to leave my key on the counter.
Discover more
coffee
Bookshelves
Car
Online movie streaming services
Comics
Shirts
Brown rice syrup
Then I sat on my kitchen floor and felt everything collapse inward.
Within weeks, they were posting couple photos.
Within three months, they were engaged.
People sent me screenshots.
I muted half my contacts.
Abby offered to help me slash his tires.
I laughed and cried and said no.
Instead, I turned all the hate inward.
He just said what everyone else thinks, I told myself. You’re great, but.
You’re funny, but. If you’d really loved him, you’d have lost the weight.
I couldn’t stand being in my body with that voice in my head.
So I started changing the only thing I could control.
I joined Abby’s gym.
The first day, I lasted eight minutes on the treadmill before my lungs lit on fire.
I pretended I had to pee, hid in the bathroom, and cried.
The second day, I went back.
Little by little, I walked farther.
Jogged. Lifted light weights. Watched form videos on YouTube in my car so I wouldn’t look stupid.
I cut back on takeout.
Learned to roast vegetables without burning them.
Logged my food obsessively. Drank more water.
For weeks, nothing seemed different.
Then my jeans got loose.
Then my face looked sharper in the mirror.
Then someone at work said, “You look really good.
Did you do something?”
Six months later, I’d lost a lot of weight.
Enough that people who hadn’t seen me in a while did double-takes. Enough that my aunt pulled me aside to whisper, “I knew you had it in you,” like I’d passed some secret test.
I got more attention.
More door holds, more smiles, more “Wow, you look amazing.”
It felt good and creepy in equal measure.
Inside, I still felt like the girl who’d been dumped for her thinner best friend.
Then came their wedding.
I knew the date from social media.
Mutual friends posted, “Can’t wait!” with ring emojis.
I muted more people.
Discover more
coffee
Brown rice syrup
Shirts
Car
Online movie streaming services
Bookshelves
Comics
Obviously, I wasn’t invited.
My plan: phone on silent, DoorDash, trash TV, bed.
At 10:17 a.m., my phone rang anyway.
Unknown number.
I answered out of habit.
“Hello?”
“Is this Larkin?” a woman asked, voice tight.
“Yes.”
Mrs. Whitlock. Perfect hair, perfect pearls, perfect passive-aggressive comments about “us girls” sticking to salad.
My stomach dropped.
“What’s going on?” I asked.
“You need to come here,” she said.
“Right now.
Lakeview Country Club. Please.
You won’t believe what happened.”
“Is Sayer okay?” I asked.
“He’s fine,” she snapped. “Just come.
Please.”
I should’ve said no.
Instead, I grabbed my keys.
The country club was 40 minutes away, manicured lawns and tasteful signs saying “Whitlock Wedding” with arrows.
Except the parking lot was chaos.
Cars half on the grass.
People in suits and dresses clustered outside, whispering.
Inside, the reception hall looked wrecked.
Chairs overturned. A tablecloth hanging crooked. A centerpiece smashed, petals and glass all over the floor.
Champagne spilled in sticky patches.
Not an accident.
Mrs.
Whitlock hurried over.
Her updo was falling apart. Mascara streaks.
She grabbed my hands like I was the EMT.
Discover more
coffee
Brown rice syrup
Shirts
Online movie streaming services
Comics
Car
Bookshelves
“Thank God you came,” she said.
“What happened?” I asked.
She pulled me close, lowering her voice.
“That girl,” she hissed. “Maren.
She was never serious about him.”
I blinked.
She looked almost pleased through her outrage.
“Maren’s been seeing another man,” she said.
“Laughing with him about how easy Sayer is. How she’d ‘enjoy the ring and see how long she could ride it.’”
My stomach twisted. Again.
“Did Sayer see them?” I asked.
“He confronted her,” she said.
“She called him boring, said she didn’t want to be tied down ‘to a man with a mom like his,’ and left.
In her dress.”
I pictured it and, against my will, let out a tiny snort.
Mrs. Whitlock squeezed my hands.
“We can’t let this ruin him,” she said.
“People are here. Family.
His boss.
To cancel would be humiliating.”
“So the wedding is off,” I said.
“For now,” she said. “But it doesn’t have to be a disaster.”
She pulled back to look me over, head to toe.
Her eyes lit with something that made my skin crawl.
“Larkin, you always loved him,” she said. “You were loyal.
Good to him.
And look at you now—you’re beautiful. You match him.”
There it was again.
“You and Sayer could have a small ceremony today,” she said.
“Just something simple. It would save face.
Everyone already knows you.
It makes sense.”
I stared at her.
“You called me here,” I said slowly, “to ask me to marry your son. At his canceled wedding. To someone else.”
She frowned.
“You’ve always wanted to be with him,” she said.
“Don’t throw away this chance because your feelings are hurt.”
I looked at the chaos around us.
The broken glass.
The overturned chairs. The empty space where a bride had decided she wanted more.
And I saw myself clearly for the first time in their story.
I wasn’t a person.
I was a backup plan.
I slid my hands out of hers.
“No,” I said.
Her eyes narrowed.
“Excuse me?”
Discover more
coffee
Car
Online movie streaming services
Shirts
Brown rice syrup
Bookshelves
Comics
“I’m not your replacement bride,” I said. “Your son cheated on me, left me, and proposed to my best friend.
You don’t get to call me like a spare tire when that blows out.”
“You’d let him be humiliated?” she snapped.
“He humiliated himself six months ago,” I said.
“This is just everyone else catching up.”
Before she could answer, I turned and walked out.
No speech. No scene.
Just… left.
I drove home, hands shaking, heart pounding.
I made tea. I sat on my couch.
I let myself feel stupid for going and proud for leaving.
At 7:42 p.m., there was a knock at my door.
Three heavy knocks.
I checked the peephole.
Sayer.
Of course.
He looked like a handsome disaster.
Shirt unbuttoned at the neck, tie gone, hair wrecked, eyes red.
I opened the door with the chain on.
He looked me over and did an actual double-take.
“Wow,” he said. “You look… incredible.”
I didn’t respond.
He exhaled.
“Today was hell,” he said.
“You know what she did.”
“I heard,” I said.
“She made me look like a joke,” he said. “In front of everyone.
My boss.
My family. It’s already online. People are sending memes.
It’s bad.”
He leaned closer to the crack in the door.
I laughed.
Just once.
“You’re serious,” I said.
He frowned, confused I wasn’t melting.
“You’ve changed,” he said, gesturing at me. “Back then, you were… you know.
You didn’t really take care of yourself. We didn’t match.
I’m just being honest.”
My stomach didn’t drop this time.
“But now?” he said.
“Now you look amazing. We’d make sense. People would get it.
It would save my reputation.
And yours. You wouldn’t be the girl I left.
You’d be the one I chose.”
There it was.
Even now, he framed it as a favor.
“You think my reputation needs saving?” I asked.
“People talk,” he said quickly. “We could turn this into a story about finally ending up with the right person.
About how we were meant to be.”
I actually smiled.
He relaxed, mistaking it.
“You know what’s funny?” I said.
“Six months ago, I might’ve said yes.”
He opened his mouth.
I didn’t let him.
“I thought if I got smaller, I’d finally be enough,” I said. “But losing weight just made it easier to see who wasn’t.”
His jaw clenched.
“That’s not fair,” he said. “You were fat.
I was honest.
At least I—”
“I was big,” I said calmly. “And I was still too good for you.”
He froze.
“You didn’t leave because I was unlovable,” I said.
“You left because you’re shallow and you wanted a trophy. Maren didn’t ruin your life.
She just played your game better.”
“You can’t talk to me like this,” he said.
“I can,” I said.
“Because I don’t need you to love me after.”
Discover more
coffee
Shirts
Online movie streaming services
Comics
Bookshelves
Car
Brown rice syrup
I slid the chain off the door.
Hope flashed across his face.
I opened it just enough to meet his eyes.
“I deserve better,” I said. “And the best part? I finally believe that.”
Then I closed the door.
Locked it.
He knocked once more, softer.
“Larkin,” he said.
“Don’t be like this.”
I walked away.
Because the biggest thing I lost wasn’t 80 pounds or whatever number is on a chart.
It was the belief that I had to earn basic respect.
My ex’s wedding imploded.
His mom tried to recruit me as his emergency bride. He showed up at my door like I was a PR strategy.
And for the first time in my life, I didn’t shrink myself to fit someone else’s idea of love.
I stayed exactly who I am.
And I shut the door.
Was the main character right or wrong?
Let’s discuss it in the Facebook comments.
